top of page

Elevated Magazines - Premium Lifestyle Content

From the superyachts making waves at Monaco to the estates redefining luxury living in Palm Beach, the automotive debuts turning heads in Geneva, and the artists commanding record prices at auction — Elevated Magazines captures the luxury lifestyle stories, brands, and cultural moments that have the world's most discerning audiences talking right now.

The Marquis of Montreal: Simon McTavish, a Lost Estate Bought Back, and the MacTavish Tartan

Oct 26
7 min read

In July 1804 the richest man in Montreal died at the age of fifty-four, in a city that had watched him arrive with little more than a Highland surname and a head for figures. His name was Simon McTavish. He had built one of the two great fur-trading concerns of North America, kept a table that was talked about from Quebec to London, and left an estate valued at £125,000. A few years before his death, three thousand miles from Montreal, he had also done something that made no business sense at all. He had bought back the land his clan had lost.

That land was Dunardry, in Knapdale, and the clan was the MacTavishes, whose name is carried today by a deep red cloth, the MacTavish tartan, which the man himself never saw. The cloth came much later. The story of the Marquis, as Montreal called him, and of the estate he paid for and the house he left behind, comes first.

The boy from Stratherrick

McTavish was born around 1750 at Stratherrick, in the hill country on the south-east side of Loch Ness. In 1764, when he was thirteen, he was sent across the Atlantic to New York in the care of his sister and her husband, Hugh Fraser, a captain in the 78th Fraser Highlanders, and put to work in the counting house of a Scottish merchant. It was a common road for a Highland boy with no land coming to him.

He learned quickly. By 1769 he was trading on his own account, by 1772 he had a partner at Detroit, and the next year his goods were going up the lakes to Grand Portage, on the north shore of Lake Superior, where the canoe routes into the beaver country began. Then the American Revolution handed him an opening. While the Continental Army held Montreal, the traders there could not get their goods west. McTavish, wintering at Detroit in 1775 and 1776, had the field almost to himself, and the furs he carried to London afterwards were worth £15,000 in a rising market.

At the end of the 1770s he settled in Montreal. Out of a loose alliance of the city's traders grew the North West Company, with McTavish and the Frobisher brothers holding the largest stake, and when Benjamin Frobisher died in 1787 McTavish took charge, with eleven of the twenty shares. Every spring the company's canoe brigades left Lachine for the far north-west, and every summer the wintering partners came down with the year's furs. For nearly two decades the man at the centre of it all was the boy from Stratherrick.

The Marquis

Montreal gave him his nickname for his elegance: his clothes, his manners and his dinners. He was a leading figure in the Beaver Club, the dining society of fur traders who had wintered in the north-west, whose evenings of toasts and songs went on into the small hours. In October 1793 he married Marie-Marguerite Chaboillez, the eighteen-year-old daughter of one of the club's founders. They tried London, where she was unhappy, and came home to Montreal in 1795. They had six children. On the slope of Mount Royal, above the town, he built a great stone house fit for the name the town had given him.

Thompson Red

The tartan that carries his clan's name has a tangled history, as most clan tartans do. The archives hold a green and red sett said to come from a manuscript by the Smith brothers of Mauchline around 1850, which may never have reached their printed book. They hold a pale blue dress tartan designed in 1958 for the newspaper owner Lord Thomson of Fleet, later accepted by the chief as the clan's dress sett. And they hold the cloth most MacTavishes wear today, which first appears in W. and A. K. Johnston's Tartans of the Clans and Septs of Scotland in 1906.

That last is the one in this story: a dark red ground crossed by broad bands of azure and black, with a narrow line of royal blue where the azure meets the red. The archives give it two other names, MacTavish Red and Thompson Red, because Thomson, Thompson and MacTavish are one name in two languages, Tavish being the Gaelic form of Thomas. In October 2003 the Lord Lyon was asked to record it as the official MacTavish tartan, in place of a near-twin in which that narrow line is black, and the chief confirmed the choice at the Stone Mountain Highland Games in Georgia that same month.

Montreal, a Saturday in June

Callum Thompson is thirty-one, a structural engineer, and best man at his brother's wedding at Christ Church Cathedral on Sainte-Catherine Street, at two in the afternoon. He has walked up McTavish Street to work most days for six years without giving the name a thought, until his brother, who has taken up the family tree, sent him a link about a fur trader with a ghost.

The groom is wearing a kilt, so the best man is wearing a kilt, in the red MacTavish that the archives also call Thompson Red, which settled the question of tartan in about a minute. The jacket took longer. A two o'clock wedding is not black tie, and the short evening jacket with silver buttons that most people picture at a Highland wedding belongs after six. In daylight the right coat is the Argyll: longer in the body, plainer in the buttons, cut like a good day jacket and worn with a long tie and a waistcoat.

He ordered it from Scottish Kilt, who had made both brothers' kilts. Their jackets for kilts are laid out by occasion, the Argyll for daytime and weddings and the Prince Charlie for black-tie evenings, each with a matching three-button waistcoat, with Irish and country styles alongside. He chose the Argyll in black with its waistcoat, and sent his chest, shoulder, sleeve and back length instead of guessing at a size, because the one thing a kilt jacket has to do is stop in the right place. It should finish just below the waistband of the kilt and leave the pleats clear. Too long and it smothers the tartan; too short and it looks borrowed.

On the day, the dark coat does exactly what it should. Against black, the red of the kilt glows instead of shouting, and the azure bands come forward like light through a window. With a white shirt, a dark green tie, green hose, brown brogues and a plain leather day sporran, Callum looks, his mother says, like a man who owns a fur company. Of all the jackets for kilts he might have chosen, the plain day coat turns out to be the one that lets the tartan do the talking.

Dunardry

The MacTavishes were an old Argyll family of modest power, whose lands lay at Dunardry in Knapdale, on the long peninsula west of Loch Fyne. They lived in the shadow of the Campbells and usually at their side, and through the eighteenth century their fortunes drained away until, in 1785, the chief, Lachlan MacTavish, had to sell Dunardry altogether.

Simon McTavish had never lived in Knapdale; his own people came from the other side of the Highlands. But he was a MacTavish by name, and after word reached him that the old chief had died in 1796, he set about buying the estate back. He paid £6,000 for it at the end of the decade. He treated it as a hobby-horse, and it never brought him any return. What he seems to have wanted was simply for Dunardry to belong to a MacTavish again.

He did not have long to enjoy it. On 6 July 1804 he died in Montreal. His will remembered friends and relations and two of the city's hospitals, the Hôtel-Dieu and the Grey Nuns' general hospital. His nephews built him a monument in the grounds of the house on the mountain, a twenty-foot column inside a walled enclosure. His widow remarried and took the children to England, and the house was boarded up.

The ghost on the mountain

An empty mansion on a hill above a city will collect stories, and this one collected plenty. People claimed to have seen the Marquis dancing on the roof by moonlight, or standing at the windows looking down at the town he had once dominated. When the house was finally pulled down in 1861, a workman is said to have fallen from the roof to his death, and the gossip blamed the old man for that too. The best of the legends has him, once the house was gone, riding his own coffin like a toboggan down the snowy slope of Mount Royal on winter nights. None of it is history, and all of it is still told.

His monument fared no better than his house. The column crumbled, the enclosure was knocked down and buried, and in 1942 a plain granite block took its place. But the city kept his name. McTavish Street runs up the west side of McGill University, and the McTavish reservoir lies just above it, on the slope where the big house stood.

At the reception, in a hotel ballroom on Sherbrooke Street, a great-aunt from Glasgow finds Callum by the bar.

"That's the Thomson red."

"MacTavish. Same thing, apparently."

"Same thing." She considers the jacket. "Your grandfather had a tie in it. Never wore it. Said it was too loud for an elder of the kirk."

"It's a wedding."

"It is." She nods at the tall windows, towards the dark bulk of the mountain. "You know one of them has a street up there."

"I walk up it every morning."

"Then mind yourself in the winter," she says. "I hear he comes down it on his coffin."

Bought back

Simon McTavish traded on a scale no Highlander before him had imagined, and the one purchase he made for no profit at all was a stretch of hill, wood and bog in Knapdale that belonged to a family he knew only by name. He did not live to do much with it. It was enough that it had been bought back.

The tartan came a century after him, red and azure and black, and the clan settled on it as its own two hundred years after he paid for Dunardry. It looks exactly right under a dark jacket at a June wedding in the city where he made his fortune, a few streets below the slope where, if you believe the stories, he still goes sledding when the moon is up.

Perrelet Casino Royale
Northrop & Johnson Yachts for Charter
Nuvolari Lenard
bottom of page